Gaza-Israel conflict

Update: Main article Gaza-Israel War

I think someone should look into that topic and report on the likelihood of any escalation esp. with Iran which seems to be close to possess weapon grade Uran.
If the conflict spirals out of control one also needs to ask what this could mean for the likelihood of an China-Taiwan war or how it might affect the Russia-Ukraine war.

I originally thought that the conflict would likely be contained and small solidarity attacks from the Hisbollah in Lebanon was more of a way to deescalate then escalate.

I still don’t understand the strategic rational of Hamas though and think we should take the topic more seriously given El-Erian‘s warning about a potential escalation.

2 Likes
1 Like

Israel prepares for ground invasion of Gaza.

Details on ground invasion are still scanty but Israel’s military general has told soldiers that the incursion is coming.

1 Like

It appears Hezbollah and Israel don’t want an escalation in Lebanon but that could easily spiral out of control.

Good well presented summary of some key elements of the conflict.

I believe a wider escalation remains unlikely but think we have to remain vigilant in order to spot any deterioration early.

This twitter account is reporting all new events around it mostly live, including what could be fake or not. In case you want to follow. https://twitter.com/sentdefender

1 Like

Did you see any good analysis about the likelihood that the conflict would escalate and involve Iran at one point @Magaly?

Here is a video of former defense secretary Espen saying he cannot imagine that at some point in time Iran would not have to be addressed with measurements ranging from more sanctions to target strikes on Iranian infrastructure.

1 Like

I am definitely not good an understanding much about geopolitical issues. But I saw this video from Iam Bremmer, which I found very helpful, explaining that what he worries about the most at the moment is that Israel makes bad mistakes in its reaction to the attack from Hamas, and that these mistakes or their reaction could lead to a greater war in the Middle East.

He says he contracts the reaction from this event similar to what happened after 9-11. And back then even the US made terrible mistakes, but the US had a much better position than Israel today.
He is very concerned about hearing from Israel’s defense minister language.

But he thinks Iran was probably aware, but did not order this. And that Iran for now is most likely in the same mindset as the US, to not escalate this, due to the global impact this will have on the economy. But also said this not with very high confidence.

Things to watch

  • Lebanon and Hezbollah, if scalation were to happen, probably would start here
  • What happens with the hostages
  • If Israel is able to put together a unified national emergency government to make better and wiser decisions
2 Likes

Israel forms emergency government with the opposition to take the country through the war.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/2023-10-11/israel-forms-war-cabinet-hezbollah-fires-at-troops-video

1 Like

Detailed operational video about the Gaza-Israel conflict. The video claims that Hamas has around 25,000 fighters and has likely been preparing for an expected Israel ground invasion long in advance. (Min 27:30)

That explains why Israel may want to continue aerial attacks and destroy Hamas infrastructure for a certain period before going in.

I believe the harder it is for Israel to fight Hamas in Gaza the lower the chances that Hezbollah feels obliged to enter the conflict in order to „save“ Hamas.

1 Like

From what I have heard so far, more sanctions against Iran cannot derail its support for Terrorism and no one wants a war with them.

“You could probably ratchet up those sanctions a little bit, but as we recall, when sanctions against Iran were at an even higher level, prior to the nuclear accord that President Obama negotiated, they were still able to support all these proxy forces all over the Middle East,” said Max Boot, Senior Fellow for National Security Studies, Council on Foreign Relations.

“Are we going to go to war with Iran? I don’t think anybody wants that either. So the problem with Iran is there’s no good options, which is why their strategy is so effective and so fiendish because they can lash out and it’s not clear what we do in response.”

Here are opinions of Ray Takeyh, Senior Fellow for Middle East Studies, Council on Foreign Relations, regarding Iran’s position on the war;

  • He doesn’t see involvement of Iran in the Northern front since they are satisfied with what has happened.
  • Takeyh doesn’t see direct war between Israel and Iran.
  • His guess is that the northern front will remain “stabilized”

I don’t think this is developing in the best way.
Apparently ground invasion has been pushed to next week due to bad weather, but it was planned for this weekend.

Iran sent a message to Israel on Saturday stressing that it does not want further escalation in the Hamas-Israel war, but that it will have to intervene if the Israeli operation in Gaza continues, two diplomatic sources with knowledge of the situation told Axios.

https://www.axios.com/2023/10/14/iran-warning-israel-hezbollah-hamas-war-gaza
https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/iran-warns-far-reaching-consequences-if-israel-not-stopped-2023-10-14/


https://twitter.com/IranIntl_En/status/1713292148005540240?t=NFYMKeZaiUJDYLJLFORCfQ&s=19

1 Like

Irans foreign minister warned about a possible imminent preemptive attack on Israel in live TV.

He states that all options are on table for Hezbollah and that Israel wouldn’t stop at Gaza and therefore Gaza must be defended from a ground invasion.

My Assessment: I think Iran wants to raise the stakes for Israel and possibly prevent it from entering Gaza. Additionally, it wants to demonstrate solidarity with its Ally. To me it is unclear if Iran or Hezbollah would indeed enter a war with Israel and to which level they would commit to it. I think one possible scenario could be increased attacks from Hezbollah in a show of solidarity to Hamas if Israel enters Gaza but stopping short off actions that would provoke a massive response from Israel.

1 Like

Analysts seem to agree that it would take Iran months to assemble a nuclear weapon but enriching uranium could be swift. There is also a consensus that Iran might use the Israel-Gaza war as deterrence to continue its nuclear program. Hence; if the war continues for 6 to 12 months, Iran may finally get a nuclear weapon, which they could use if its proxies in the region lose the war.

(Min 14:37-15:55, Min 27:17-34:52)

(min 6:10-22:00)

1 Like

There has been a large explosion at the Al-Ahli Arab Hospital yesterday which killed almost 500 people according to the Gaza health industry.

While the number of deaths is disputed it is certainly the worst escalation in Gaza since the beginning of the war that enraged the Arab world.

Early open source intelligence seems to indicate that Israel might not been behind the attack but there will be no certainty for many months or ever.

The horrific incident is raising the stakes for Israel in case of a ground invasion

2 Likes

Prospects of a wider escalation in the middle east are looking more dangerous than ever. For now my basecase scenario (70%+) remains non escalatory but we need to have a deeper look as tensions are starting to increase and the risks are higher than ever.

What happened?

On december 25 general Sayyed Razi Mousavi was killled in an targeted airstrike south of Damascus, Syria. He he has been described as Iran’s ‘most influential’ commander in Syria [1] which is emphasized by Iran’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei leading his funeral. [2]

On januar 2 Saleh al-Arouri was killed in a suburb of Beirut, Lebanon through an airstrike which killed 5 other officials. He was Hamas deputy leader and second in command. As a consequence Hezbollah leader Hasan Nasrallah vowed revenge. [3]

Israel has a policy of not confirming attacks beyond it’s soil but it is highly likely that it is responsible for those attacks.

On january 3 two bombs killed 95 participants of Qassim Suleimani memorial in Kerman, Iran. This tactic of using two delayed bombs is a tactic commonly used by terrorist groups like IS who is active in Iran. [4] No major military or political figures have been present at the memorial. [5] There have been speculations that this attack could try to draw Iran deeper into the conflict or could have been an inside job. Iran’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei promised a “harsh response”.

Assessment
From what i heard Iran has no large interest entering the conflict as this could be regime threatening. Hezbollah should also not have an interest entering the conflict given it’s weak prospects of achieving a positiv outcome and Lebanons economical crisis.
That said both parties will loose prestige and deterrence if they tolerate targeted high profile killings in their zones of influences. They could therefore feel pressured to have a certain kind of response.

I think it is very unlikely that Israel is behind the latest bombing in Iran given that it usually uses very targeted attacks on leading figures and would avoid attacks on the Iranian public in order to continue exploiting the divide between the Iranian public and the regime.
Instead, dangerously the bombing which is the deadliest since 1979 increases pressure on Iran to react and could serve as a pretense and justification for a wider escalation.
It needs to be seen who they deem responsible after they conclude their investigation and how they will react.

2 Likes

Hezbollah seems to want to continue refraining itself from a full-scale war with Israel. Hassan Nasrallah, Hezbollah Secretary-General said while condoling Al-Arouri that they have been losing many fighters in the south of Lebanon because they have been calculating their move carefully in order not to give Israel any reason for an all-out war.

PBS NewsHour | Killing of Hamas leader deepens concerns of war spreading | Season 2024 | PBS (minute 3:37)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oij8PpHpeI8 (minute 0:50)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3FtMbZpa5fs

Unlike at the start of the war, Hezbollah has now lost an advantage in the conflict. Gaza has been weakened; hence a full-scale war with Israel, will result in diversion of Israeli resources from Gaza to the South of Lebanon.

Today, ISIS claimed responsibility for the Iranian twin bombings. ISIS claims that two suicide bombers carried the attack, which is different from Iran’s claim that the attack involved two bombs triggered remotely. The ISIS claim looks more appealing given that the attack was aimed at civilians and that a source told IRNA that the explosion “was the result of a suicide bomber’s action”.

Assessment
Unless Israel carries out targetted attacks on Hezbollah leadership, I think it’s unlikely that the conflict between Israel and Hezbollah will result in a full-blown conflict. However, the chance of miscalculation is still high.

I think the real danger lies on Iran whose president had already pointed a finger on Israel following Kerman bombing. It remains to be seen whether they will accept ISIS’s claim or continue blaming Israel for the bombings. If they conclude that Israel is behind the attack, they might be forced to carry out deterrence, possibly through Hezbollah and its other proxies in the region.

1 Like

I agree that the time window for Hezbollah to draw Israel into a two sided war has passed as Israel largely controls Gaza by now and is starting to withdraw some first troops from the area.

The fact that Israel chose to act on Syrian soil to kill al-Arouri also points to a strong and confident position of Israel.

——————

Apparently Iranian state tv now says that investigators believe based on camera footage that the explosions have been suicide attacks. Shortly after this report came out ISIS claimed responsibility for the attack.

Assessment
Based on everything I saw today I believe the risk of escalation is smaller than initially feared and it is highly likely that there will be no broader escalation esp. with recent evidence when it comes to the bombings.

1 Like

Tensions have risen in the Middle East in the past few days after an air strike on a Iranian diplomatic compound in Syria killed senior Iranian millitary officials. Iran blamed Israel for the attack and vowed to retaliate.

Yesterday, Israeli military disrupted GPS signals, placing Israel residents in Beirut in an attempt to confuse GPS-guided drones or missiles that Iran or its proxies might fire at Israel.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-04-04/tel-aviv-gps-is-scrambled-over-fears-of-iran-revenge-attack

Assessment

Judging from past events and the current economic situation in Iran, I still don’t think Iran will get directly involved in the war. However, the danger of miscalculation remains and it’s worthy to keep monitoring the situation.

2 Likes